The electoral college is the system used to elect the president of the united states the popular vote has less power than the electoral vote for this reason, swing states are given a lot of. The electoral college is based on congressional seats, so when a state gains or loses house members, its number of electors also changes several states are expected to gain seats after the 2020. Leib & mark fi paginated ftp 1_cdoc 1/30/2008 2:53 pm 105 democratic principle and electoral college reform ethan j leib & eli j mark † introduction the electoral college is a relic from another time and is in tension with. The electoral college is comprised of 538 people, known as electors, chosen nationwide to meet in their home states and cast one vote per person for president and vice president michigan has 16 electors to reflect the number of senators and representatives it has in the us congress. 1 from understanding the presidency, 3rd edition (ny: longman, 2002), pp 57-72 reevaluating the electoral college james p pfiffner alexander hamilton concluded in federalist no 68 that the electoral method of choosing the chief.
The argument for repealing the electoral college is straightforward the main repeal argument is simple: that the electoral college is not directly democratic and thus violates the principle of. National popular vote matters in neither system, the electoral college is an artifact of the constitution, the nomination process does not require a constitutional amendment to be changed, most states in the. Many argue that the electoral college “violates democratic principles of fair elections”  essentially, they contend that the “democratic standard of political equity—of one person, one vote,” is violated by the electoral college [9. Chapter i the origins and meaning of the electoral college gary l gregg ii its critics and supporters both have it rightthe electoral college does not work as it was intended to work by the framers of our constitution.
Supporters argue that the principle of one-person, one-vote should not pertain to the electoral college, just as it does not pertain to the us senate they point out that the college was designed to underscore the federal nature of the us government. The electoral college is anything but outdated in a deeply divided nation, a candidate shouldn’t be able to win by appealing only to urban sophisticates. Understanding the electoral college a republic is a nation whose guiding principal is that the rule of law and a constitution take precedence over majority rule the electoral college. Presidential election process learn about the presidential election process, including the electoral college, caucuses and primaries, and the national conventions. The electoral college minimizes the impact of fraud, isolating it to the one or two states where the vote was close, disputed, and relevant to the electoral college balance addressing alternative.
The fundamental concern with the electoral college is its representational unreliability ie, the risk that the electoral vote will contradict the popular vote the primary purpose of this section is to show that the ec's representational unreliability is a direct consequence of our undersized house of representatives. The electoral college system the founders designed requires two rounds of voting—one being a popular at the state level, and then another by the delegates chosen by the citizens of that state in their popular vote. Understanding the electoral college civics/government democracy us government in several recent presidential elections, the popular vote—the national totals of all voters in an election—and the electoral college vote, which is the political process that actually chooses the president, have been inconsistent.
But that is less a product of the electoral college and more a product of the way states apportion electors in every state but maine and nebraska, electors are awarded on a winner-take-all basis. The principle behind the electoral college is similar to the principle that determines the composition of the senate, wherein every state is deemed equal, no matter its size (idea) essentially, the size of a state does not determine the state’s value. The official us electoral college web site, providing current information about the presidential election, information about the roles and responsibilities of state officials and electors, instructions for state officials and electors, the timeline of key dates for the presidential election, information about laws and legal requirements related to the presidential election and the electors.
In contrast, the electoral college provides representation for both the population at large and the states it thereby tempers and limits the power of majority rule, which has two other advantages. The evolution and destruction of the original electoral college : quantity in basket all patriots interested in restoring the framers' original plan will recognize the need to understand this unique process • the role of independent electors • electoral votes are nominating votes • the principle of federalism • the subversion. This feature is not available right now please try again later. The electoral college system further distorts the one-person, one-vote principle of democracy because electoral votes are not distributed according to population.
Hence, the electoral college was instituted as part of the checks and balances needed to prevent the concentration of political power, including the influence of powerful electoral factions by and large, the opponents of the electoral college consider america to be a democracy based on the primacy of majoritarian rule. Electoral college: electoral college, the system by which the president and vice president of the united states are chosen it was devised by the framers of the united states constitution to provide a method of election that was feasible, desirable, and consistent with a republican form of government for the results. The electoral college makes it harder to steal elections because votes must be stolen in the right state in order to change the outcome of the electoral college with so many swing states, this is hard to predict and hard to do. The electoral college is not some kind of university or school it is a system in which each us state is given a certain number of voting representatives to cast ballots during an election the number of electors has varied throughout american history but in recent elections there have been a total of 538 electors divided up between the states.
Understanding the us electoral college every four years, the us elects a president, but voters don't have the final say the electoral college really chooses the president, a month after the. The current call for change although groups like the league of women voters have long supported the abolition of the electoral college, 1 the protracted proceedings in florida as well as the apparent disparity between the popular and the electoral college vote have further fueled calls to abolish the electoral college critics urge a replacement of the electoral college with a straightforward.