The virginia plan and new jersey plan formed the compromise of the us senate and house of represenatives the virginia plan called for votes of population (house of represenatives) and the new jersey plan called for a fixed state vote (senate) a law must pass through both house to become passed. The virginia plan was by the people where as the new jersey plan was by the states the legislature consisted of two houses: senate and house of representatives. The delegates for the virginia plan were not too happy with the new jersey plan call for a weaker central government a weak central government might as well not even be a central government in the first place, for it will not do any good. The virginia plan, new jersey plan, and the great compromise the road to the constitution conclusion after the colonists gained their independence from england on july 4, 1776, they decided they needed a new form of government.
The virginia plan and the new jersey plan were two proposals on how to restructure the american form of government this lesson will describe both of those plans and explain how a compromise. The constitutional convention was held in philadelphia in 1787 the great compromise combined elements of the new jersey plan, put forth by william paterson, that proposed two representatives. New jersey plan opposite of the virginia plan, it proposed a single-chamber congress in which each state had one vote this created a conflict with representation between bigger states, who wanted control befitting their population, and smaller states, who didn't want to be bullied by larger states. Under the new jersey plan congress has only one house and states would have equal votes and representation argument#3 the virginia plan gives larger states too much power in the vote.
New jersey plan after two weeks of debating the virginia plan , a counterproposal was put forth by william patterson, which has become known as the new jersey plan (or the small state plan or the patterson plan. The new jersey delegates to the constitutional convention, led by william paterson (1745–1806) proposed an alternative to the virginia plan on june 15, 1787 the new jersey plan was designed to protect the security and power of the small states by limiting each state to one vote in congress, as under the articles of confederation. Start studying new jersey plan vs virginia plan learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. On may 29, 1787, virginia delegate edmund randolph proposed what became known as the virginia plan written primarily by fellow virginian james madison, the plan traced the broad outlines of what would become the us constitution: a national government consisting of three branches with checks and balances to prevent the abuse of power.
Plan,” alternately called “the new jersey plan” or “the paterson plan,” proposed on june 15, 1787 the document was a response to the virginia plan, which would have given proportional power to the states based on their number of citizens the key feature of patterson’s proposal was giving equal power to. American government summer 2011 compare and contrast the virginia plan, the new jersey plan, and the connecticut plan—contrast their fundamental ideas and explain the influence each had on the design of the modern american legislature. All the delegates debated the virginia plan for over a week, when william paterson introduced the new jersey plan the ideas paterson were a direct attack on the virginia delegates plan it preserved the structure of the current national government under the articles but did allow for greater power to be rested in the national government.
The virginia plan (also known as the randolph plan, after its sponsor, or the large-state plan) was a proposal by virginia delegates for a bicameral legislative branch the plan was drafted by james madison while he waited for a quorum to assemble at the constitutional convention of 1787. When you use a browser, like chrome, it saves some information from websites in its cache and cookies clearing them fixes certain problems, like loading or formatting issues on sites in chrome. The smaller states favored the new jersey plan according to the new jersey plan, the number of representatives would be the same for each state a delegate from connecticut, roger sherman, proposed a two-house legislature, consisting of a senate and a house of representatives.
Quick answer the new jersey plan was a proposed government for the united states developed by william paterson in 1787 the smaller states opposed the virginia plan presented by james madison because they feared that it would allow the more populous states to dominate the government. The virginia plan proproposed representation based on population larger states prefered this plan the new jersey plan proposed that every state have an equal amount of representatives smaller. Debate on the new jersey plan (june 16) mr paterson, said as he had on former occasion given his sentiments on the plan proposed by mr randolph he would now avoiding repetition as much as possible give his reasons in favor of that proposed by hinself. Delegates from the larger, more populous states favored the virginia plan, which called for each state to have a different number of representatives based on the state’s population delegates from smaller states supported the new jersey plan, under which each state would send the same number of representatives to congress.
A compromise was reached yesterday (june 29th, 1787) in philadelphia combining the new jersey plan and the virginia plan this has been a major conflict for quite a while the new jersey plan was debated for four days, but the larger states rejected it. The virginia plan provided the framework, and after much debate, expansion, development, and compromise by the framers, became the constitution of the united states neither the virginia nor the new jersey plans were immediately printed for the delegates.
The new jersey and virginia plans were created in order to address the issue of representation in the congress during the 1787 convention in philadelphia. The virginia plan the powers of the government should be divided among three separate branches: a legislative branch for making laws an executive branch for enforcing laws and a judicial branch, for interpreting laws. Also of interest are charles pinckney's plan, the new jersey plan, and the british plan the inclusion of an executive was a key provision of the virginia plan, and is a key provision of the constitution this is an entirely new concept for the national government, as the confederation had no executive worthy of the name however, the.